Intel i9 versus AMD Ryzen processor
Geplaatst: 19 feb 2020 18:53
Als je b.v. zou kunnen kiezen tussen een AMD Ryzen 9 3950X en een Intel i9 9900KS wat zou dan voor Hauptwerk de voorkeur hebben?
Nederlandstalig Hauptwerk forum
https://www.pcorgel.nl/
For whatever they're worth, some other general thoughts/suggestions about choosing CPUs:
- All else being equal, newer CPU generations usually perform better than older ones. (One would hope that a recent i9 should out-perform an otherwise-equivalent older i7, for example.)
- CPU base clock speed matters much more than max/turbo-boost speed (since the latter will only be reached briefly and cannot be sustained).
- The CPU having support for the AVX-512 instruction set should be a big plus for Hauptwerk performance, especially since it increases the number of SIMD registers from 16 (AVX/AVX-2) to 32 (AVX-512). Some of the recent higher-end workstation/desktop Xeon, i9 and i7 CPUs support AVX-512, but as far as I know no laptop CPUs yet support it.
As a matter of fact I highly recommend that you don't base your selection on the max turbo speed, Also, in the bios, all the turbo and throttling options should be disabled so your CPU performs *always* at 100% (no speed variation
Be careful, buying the latest most powerful CPU comes witch comes with a high premium to pay (a few months later that processor will probably cost a lot less). Also, workstations and servers type of processors, also come with a premium (price of the processor, motherboard, memory ) and are optimized for some specific type of processing not necessarily used by Hauptwerk.
Also the power (and memory required) are based on many factors, to name a few:
- Your level as an organist... are you a Cameron Carpenter type of organist playing a few hundred notes a second! or a beginner (more notes = more polyphony = more processing etc)
-Are you playing surround sample sets (and new surround sample sets with multiple recorded tracks can generate 2-3-4 more polyphony)
- Are you playing only "intimate" organs, smaller one, like 2 manuals, 25 stops with 2 seconds reverberation or large (50-75-100) stops cathedral-like organs (again more polyphony, more memory needed)
Dirk schreef:Ik heb het blad gelezen. Heel mooi systeem.
Processor: AMD Ryzen 9 3900X
Cpu-koeler: Scythe, Mugen 5 Rev B,(SCMG-5100)
Moederbord: Gigabyte X570 Aorus Elite
Werkgeheugen: Crucial DIMM kit 32GB,DDR4-3200,CL22(CT2K16G4DFD832A)
SSD: Corsair Force Series Gen.4PCleMP600 1TB,M.2(CSSD-F1000GBMP600)
Grafische kaart: MSI Geforce GT 1030 2GH LP OC, 2GB GDDRS(V809-2498R)
Behuizing: Fractal Design Define R6 USB-CBlack(FD-CA-DEF-R6C-BK)
Voeding: Be quiet Pure Power 11 500W ATX2.4(BN293)
Besturingssysteem: Windows 10
Voor zo`n 1600 Euro.
Dit is naar wens goed aan te passen.
Alleen de prijs wordt dan wel anders.